Cracking the Code – To Pay or Not to Pay for Mortgage Points?

  • AUTHOR: editor
  • POSTED ON: June 7, 2023

Amidst the tumultuous landscape of soaring mortgage rates, an anxious hush falls over the room as borrowers diligently gather around their laptops, their eyes fixated on the ever-fluctuating numbers on the screen.

The Federal Reserve’s decision to raise the short-term fed funds rate has sent shockwaves through the housing market, causing average mortgage rates to more than double since 2021.

In this desperate quest to regain control over their financial destiny, these borrowers find themselves on a relentless pursuit to uncover any means to manage the weighty burden of interest. And as they delve deeper into the labyrinth of options, one prevailing choice emerges – the allure of mortgage discount points beckons them with the promise of much-needed interest relief.

Mortgage discount points serve as a singular expense that borrowers pay to their lender, enabling them to secure a reduced interest rate on their home loan. While these points do increase the closing costs as borrowers are required to pay more upfront, they yield valuable benefits in the form of lower monthly mortgage payments and a decrease in the overall interest paid over the loan’s duration.

Essentially, when a lender mentions the option to “buy down” the rate, they are alluding to the utilization of mortgage discount points.

When considering mortgage points, it is important to note that they typically amount to 1% of the total loan value. For instance, if you have a mortgage of $300,000, one point would cost you $3,000. By option for mortgage discount points, borrowers can typically lower their interest rate by 0.25%.

It’s worth distinguishing mortgage discount points from origination points, which are fees paid to lenders for providing the loan. Origination points, on the other hand, are intended to cover the overhead costs associated with the loan process.

Why Should I Pay Upfront for a Lower Rate?

Paying mortgage points becomes a viable consideration when the goal is to reduce the monthly interest expense, thereby making mortgage payments more manageable. This approach proves beneficial in situations where your credit score doesn’t qualify you for the most favorable interest rates, yet you possess additional funds to contribute towards the down payment and seek an upfront tax deduction.

By opting for mortgage points, you can strategically align your financial circumstances to achieve greater affordability and potential tax advantages.

Time Frame Matters

Before committing to paying mortgage points, it is crucial to evaluate the timeframe required to recover the upfront costs. Let’s consider an example – if you are financing $300,000 and decide to purchase two points, resulting in a rate reduction from &% to 6.5%, your monthly payment would decrease from $1,995.91 to $1,896.20.

To calculate the breakeven point, a simple approach is dividing the amount paid for the points ($6,000) by the monthly savings ($99.70).

By using this method, it would take approximately 60 months or five years to recoup the costs. Additionally, if you factor in the potential tax deduction associated with paying the points, the recoupment period may be even shorter.

If you have intentions of residing in the home for at least five years, there is an additional factor worth considering – the possibility of refinancing your home in case interest rates decline.

Reflecting on my personal experience, I was fortunate to purchase my first home in the early 2000s when interest rates were comparable to today’s level. Back then, a 6.5% interest rate was considered favorable. However, a few years later, interest rates plummeted to historic lows, leading me to refinance my home at a lower rate.

If you believe there is a reasonable chance that you would refinance the home within that five-year timeframe, it might be prudent to postpone paying more cash upfront for mortgage points.

This approach allows for greater flexibility to capitalize on potentially more advantageous interest rates down the line.

Some Other Methods to Lower the Rate

Lowering your mortgage rate doesn’t solely rely on paying for mortgage discount points. There are alternative strategies to explore, such as actively shopping around and comparing mortgage rates from various lenders.

Additionally, it’s vital to ensure that your credit is in optimal condition. If your credit score is teetering between fair and good, paying down some credit cards can potentially boost your score and qualify you for more affordable financing options.

Another avenue to consider is opting for a 15- or 20-year mortgage term if your financial circumstances permit. In certain cases, choosing a shorter term can lead to mortgage rate concessions, ultimately resulting in substantial savings of tens or even hundreds of thousands of dollars by paying off the home sooner than the standard 30-year period.

In the quest to manage the burden of interest and make mortgage payments more affordable, borrowers have a range of options to consider. While paying for mortgage discount points can be enticing, it’s essential to evaluate the potential benefits and weigh them against other strategies.

Shopping around for competitive mortgage rates, improving your credit score, and exploring shorter loan terms are all viable alternatives that can lead to substantial savings.

Each borrower’s situation is unique, and it’s crucial to assess individual circumstances, long-term plans, and the likelihood of refinancing before committing to any particular approach.

By carefully considering these factors and making informed decisions, borrowers can navigate the complex landscape of mortgage rates and ultimately find the most effective path toward their financial goals!

Updated June 7, 2023
Back To Top